Board Thread:Suggestions/@comment-4801337-20190515135009/@comment-27794543-20190522005402

I moved Spacekru, but I'm waiting till tomorrow or Thursday for a another move or two (tonight isn't the best time given it be lost in all the edits related to the new episode airing). If there's no objections by Sunday, then we can do mass moves.

Impact of current moves is minimal given we're mostly moving to existing redirects. There is slightly more work with pages that have multiple redirects (e.g. Coalition with 12 redirects), since each redirect has to be fixed (double redirects don't work).

Another thing to consider is pages like "Sky People/Crime and Punishment". Should we move it to "Sky People Crime and Punishment" or keep it as a subpage? That is, do we consider it to be it's own independent topic or do we consider it to be intrinsic to "Sky People" page? It's definitely a subtopic of Sky People society, but how should we treat such pages?

Another example, if we wanted separate pages for Sky People history or Grounder religion, do we create subpages or independent pages? This is also similar to "Trigedasleng/Vocabulary" and "Trigedasleng/Linguistics".

When the article topic is an object (i.e. person, place, group, item, event, etc.), it's easy to argue for a top-level page – and I agree with this. But when it's not, there's a bit of murky region.

We are not Wikipedia, we don't attempt to follow all of Wikipedia guidelines, so just because Wikipedia doesn't use subpages in main-namespace doesn't mean we can't. This is especially so since we are planning to continue using subpages in main-namespace for at least some pages (i.e. transcripts, galleries), so we can't argue that we don't do that here.

Also the coding argument doesn't work for this type of pages. Unlike "Grounders/Nightblood" which always required code (or redirect) to do "Nightblood", whether the page is called "Sky People/Crime and Punishment" or "Sky People Crime and Punishment", a redirect or piping will still be used since 99% of the time, in the paragraphs it won't be those exact words used.

There's nothing preventing us from making these pages top-level, but there is also nothing requiring us to do so...