Talk:Gabriel Santiago/@comment-36180144-20190903221535

Seems wrong (or at least highly misleading) to list Clarke as one of Gabriel's kills, no?

He did stop her heart as part of a procedure... but doctors do that now IRL, even removing hearts for transplants or other procedures, without having "killed" the patient. Clarke was clearly never really gone, or she couldn't have come back. Her mind clearly remained alive and in her own body, which is key; if her body had truly died, it would be unusable to any mind (whether her own, or as a host). Which means there was no actual death, which logically means nobody killed her.

Maybe an argument could be made that Gabriel indirectly killed Josephine (or helped) since he conducted the procedure that allowed getting rid of her. That seems like a stretch to me, but is still more accurate than "Gabriel killed Clarke by temporarily stopping her heart in order to save her life."