User blog comment:ILoveRichardHarmon/Finn dead/@comment-26500342-20151118033551/@comment-26247132-20151119172407

I don't think anyone disagrees that Murphy was a bully in Season 1. The difference is that with Murphy, there was really no surprise; there was a reason they banished him and not just because he tried to get "justice" by killing Charlotte.

With Finn, he played himself off as this chivalrous, nice guy who just wants peace when he was really cheating on his girlfriend and keeping secrets the entire time. Plus, he didn't really do anything useful even though he tried to insert himself as some sort of leader.